Nucleophilic Acyl Substitution (Carboxylic Acid Derivatives)

These reactions are both nucleophilic acyl substitution under basic conditions. See problem 705 for the mechanism in detail.

Esters are prepared from a carboyxlic acid and an alcohol (Fischer esterification).

So the problem becomes, "how can you prepare this ester from an alochol and a carboxylic acid, each containing three carbons? (propene)"

The "pair" of carboxylic acid and alcohol to make this ester is propanoic acid and propanol.

From propene, to make propanol, just do an anti-Markovnikov H₂O addition using borane (BH₃ or B₂H₆) then hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂).

To make propanoic acid, oxidize propanol to propanoic acid using Jones reagent (aqueous chromium).

You can also convert propanoic acid to its acid chloride using SOCl₂, and then add propanol.

Adding LiAlH₄ to an ester yields two alcohols. The carbonyl "side" becomes one alcohol, and the ester "side" becomes the other alcohol.

So there are two esters that would yield these two alcohols after reduction with LiAlH₄.

To answer this problem, you must be familiar with the nucleophilic acyl substitution mechanism.

In this mechanism, the nucleophile (methanol) becomes the -OCH₃ group in the ester.

At least 80% of second semester organic chemistry is two mechnanisms: nucleophilic acyl addition and nucleophilic acyl substitution. It's worth your time to become familiar with these mechanisms. See problems 705 (basic conditions), 706 (acidic conditions), 707, and 708.

This is a good mechanism to know (nucleophilic acyl substitution). If you don't understand it, see problems 706 and 708.

Acidic mechanisms only appear complicated because they contain several proton transfer steps.

Nucleophilic acyl substitution mechanisms have only three real steps- the "up, down, and kick."

First, the nucleophile attacks the carbonyl carbon, forming a tetrahedral intermediate (the "up").

Then the carbonyl reforms (the "down") and a leaving group leaves (the "kick").

This carbonyl has two leaving groups attached to it- each of those oxygens can take part in a nucleophilic acyl substitution reaction and form a new carbonyl product.

First the Grignard attacks the oxidation state IV carbonyl carbon (4 oxygen bonds, so oxidation state 4). The carbonyl itself will act as a leaving group and form a tetrahedral intermediate. But tetrahedral intermediates don't last if there are any leaving groups attached to the carbon, so the ^-O will "come back down again", kick off an oxygen leaving group, and reform the carbonyl.

Then a second equivalent of Grignard will attack that carbonyl (an ester), and we will do another nucleophilic acyl substitution reaction to form yet another carbonyl.

Finally, the third carbonyl doesn't have any leaving groups built in (it's a ketone), so when the third equivalent of Grignard attacks it, it will do a nucleophilic acyl addition reaction, and the product will be an alcohol.

Notice that as the reaction progresses the oxidation state of the carbonyl carbon (number of oxygen bonds attached to it) goes down form 4 to 3 to 2 and then to 1.

Oxidation state III carbonyls (esters, acid chlorides) contain a built-in leaving group (such as ^-OR or ^-Cl) and so undergo nucleophilic acyl substitution reactions. The product is another carbonyl.

Oxidation state II carbonyls (aldehydes and ketones) do not contain a built-in leaving group and so undergo nucleophilc acyl addition reactions (instead of substitution). The product is an alcohol.

Because Grignards react with all carbonyls- esters and aldehydes/ketones- esters and acid chlorides will react twice with Grignards: once in a Nuc Acyl Sub mechanism to form a ketone, which will then react with another equivalent of Grignard in a Nuc Acyl Add mechanism to form an alcohol.