Grignard and Masked Carbanions (alcohols from carbonyls)

Problem # 672

Compound A has molecular formula C₆H₁₂O and shows a sharp peak at 1,710 cm^-1 in its IR spectrum.

Treatment with 1 equivalent of phenyl Grignard yields compound B, which has formula C₁₂H₁₈O and whose IR shows a broad peak at 3,350 cm^-1.

Compound B's ^₁H NMR spectrum is shown below. Determine the structures of compounds A and B.

Solution

Let's use steps similar those outlined in problem 662 to solve this NMR structure elucidation problem.

1. Are there any hints?

Yes, from the IR peaks. The starting material is a carbonyl (sharp IR peak at ~1,700 cm^-1) and the product is an alcohol (broad IR peak ~3,300 cm^-1).

2. How many IHD are in each compound? (also known as degrees of unsaturation or DBE).

C₆H₁₂O is the same as C₆H₁₂ (ignore oxygen) which should be C₆H₁₄ if fully saturated (C_nH_2n+2). It's missing 2 hydrogens so C₆H₁₂O has 1 IHD. This 1 IHD must be the carbonyl.

C12H18O is the smae as C12H18 which should be C12H26 if fully saturated. It's missing 8 hydrogens so it has 4 IHD. The benzene from the Grignard reagent must account for all 4 IHD.

3. Draw some C₆H₁₂O and C₁₂H₁₈O structures and elminate those that don't fit the data, then learn and repeat.

Things we know from the problem and NMR:

The starting material is a carbonyl and we're adding a Grignard, so we expect the product to be an alcohol. The NMR shows a peak that disappears with D₂O addition, which also confirms that the product is an alcohol.
The product must have a benzene ring because the reagent was phenyl Grignard. That accounts for the aromatic signals (~7 ppm) and the 4 IHD in the product.
the NMR shows a doublet with an integration of 6 and a multiplet with an integration of 1. This is the splitting pattern on an isopropyl group.
The NMR also shows a quartet with an integration of 2 and a triplet with an integration of 3. This is the splitting pattern of an ethyl group.

Once you have a few clues from the NMR, start drawing structures! And then elminiate those that do not fit the data (too many signals, wrong multiplicity/integrations etc.).

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 672 submitted by Matt on July 18, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (NMR), Grignard and Masked Carbanions (alcohols from carbonyls)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): Grignard, proton NMR

Problem # 671

You may have noticed that the "solvent of choice" for many organometallic compounds such as Grignard reagents is ether (short for diethyl ether).

Why is it that for Grignard reactions this solvent is used over ethyl acetate, or protic solvents such as ethanol?

Solution

Grignards behave as though they are carbanions (negatively charged carbons), and so are very basic. There are so basic that they will deprotonate any O-H or N-H bond. So protic solvents such as water or ethanol aren't suitable for Grignard reactions; the Grignard reagent will react with the alcohol in an acid-base reaction.

In fact, water is used after a Grignard reaction to quench the Grignard reagent.

Grignards are also nucleophilic, and so react with carbonyls (which are electrophiles).

Ethyl acetate contins a carbonyl and would get attacked by a Grignard reagent, and so also isn't a suitable solvent for a Grignard reaction.

Diethyl ether doesn't have any acidic protons and isn't electrophilic and so won't react with a Grignard reagent, so it makes a good solvent.