Textbook: Solomons 10th Ed. (2009)

The trick to these retrosynthesis problems is to determine where the connections or "cuts" were made.

The carbonyl carbon becomes an alcohol after a Grignard reaction, so that's where the "cut" must be.

Note that there can often be more than one correct answer to these types of problems.

For a), adding propyl Grignard to acetone or methyl Grignard to 2-pentanone will result in the product.

We can also use two equivalents of methyl Grignard with 4-carbon ester, such as ethyl butanoate. Esters contains a build in leaving group (^-OR) and so react twice with Grignards.

For b), adding phenyl Grignard to cyclopentanone will do the job.

The purpose of this problem is to illustrate that there are often several routes to prepare a single molecule.

For the left route:

1. Br₂/FeBr₃ adds a bromine to benzene via EAS.
2. Mg/ether converts bromobenzene to phenyl Grignard (a nucleophile).
3. Phenyl Grignard attacks the aldehyde.
4. A protic workup gets rid of all negative charges (and quenches the Grignard reagent).

For the right route:

1. Benzene undergoes Friedel-Crafts acylation (an EAS reaction) to form the ketone.
2. The ketone is then reduced to an alcohol using NaBH₄.

Note that both methods add a carbon chain to benzene, a step that is quite common in synthesis problems!

This carbonyl has two leaving groups attached to it- each of those oxygens can take part in a nucleophilic acyl substitution reaction and form a new carbonyl product.

First the Grignard attacks the oxidation state IV carbonyl carbon (4 oxygen bonds, so oxidation state 4). The carbonyl itself will act as a leaving group and form a tetrahedral intermediate. But tetrahedral intermediates don't last if there are any leaving groups attached to the carbon, so the ^-O will "come back down again", kick off an oxygen leaving group, and reform the carbonyl.

Then a second equivalent of Grignard will attack that carbonyl (an ester), and we will do another nucleophilic acyl substitution reaction to form yet another carbonyl.

Finally, the third carbonyl doesn't have any leaving groups built in (it's a ketone), so when the third equivalent of Grignard attacks it, it will do a nucleophilic acyl addition reaction, and the product will be an alcohol.

Notice that as the reaction progresses the oxidation state of the carbonyl carbon (number of oxygen bonds attached to it) goes down form 4 to 3 to 2 and then to 1.

Let's solve this NMR structure elucidation problem using steps similar to those used in problem 662.

1. Are there any hints?

Compound A has one oxygen and after treatment with aqueous chromium becomes compound B, which has two oxygens. This means A is probably an alcohol, B is probably a carboxylic acid.

Compound B is then treated with methanol under acidic conditions to form compound C. These are conditions for a Fischer esterification, so C is probably the methyl ester.

2. How many IHD are there?

Compound A: C₅H₁₂O = C₅H₁₂ should be C₅H₁₂ (C_nH_2n+2) so 0 IHD.

Compound B: C₅H₁₀O₂ = C₅H₁₀ should be C₅H₁₂. Missing 2H, so 1 IHD.

Compound C: C₆H₁₂O₂ = C₆H₁₂ should be C₆H₁₄. Missing 2H, so 1 IHD.

These IHD counts fit our assumptions from part 1).

3. Draw some structures and eliminate, learn, repeat.

Some clues from the NMR:

• The isopropyl splitting pattern is present: d(6) (signal c at ~0.9 ppm) and multiplet(1) (signal b at ~2.4 ppm).
• The s(3) at ~3.7 ppm is probably the methyl group from the methyl ester.
• We know from before we have one IHD, and it's probably an ester.

So start drawing structures and eliminate those that don't fit the data!